Dezeen Wire: the restoration of historic tea clipper the Cutty Sark in London by Grimshaw architects has been derided by architecture critics and conservation experts after being officially reopened by the Queen yesterday. Here's a round up of what people are saying.
Writing in The Guardian, Steve Rose says the decision to sit the ship on a glass plinth has resulted in the impression that: "It's no longer a ship, nor quite a building, but some bizarre hybrid of the two." He claims that the experience improves once inside though. "There's something bracing about standing 'underwater' and looking up along the ship's copper-lined keel."
The Telegraph reports that conservation groups are upset that Grimshaw's intervention obscures the lines of the ship's hull, quoting sailor and architect Julian Harrap who said: "Why on earth hoick it up into the air? Why do you have to put these bloody great beams right through the middle of it, to damage the fabric of it?"
Over on Twitter, Building Design editor Amanda Baillieu asks, "Would it have been a nobler end if the Cutty Sark had sunk?", while the Sunday Times architecture critic Hugh Pearman said, "Haven't been there yet but does restored Cutty Sark looks like a ship half-in, half-out, of a bottle?".
Meanwhile, the BBC reported that Cutty Sark director Richard Doughty defended the renovation, claiming the solution creates "a very different experience, offering a light environment in the Cutty Sark's new elevated position."
- Scenography by A.A. Studio
- Dominey Pavilion by Lightroom Studio
- Shell by ARTechnic architects
- Petter Dass Museum by Snøhetta
- Mountainside home by Kidosaki Architec…ts extends out into the sky
- Freshwater bathing pond to open in Lon…don's King's Cross
- Farming Kindergarten by Vo Trong Nghia… Architects
- Casamoro Condominiums by G.Lab* of Gan…sam Partners
- CF Architects builds its own timber an…d glass office on the side of a mid-century home
Sign up for a daily roundup
of all our stories