Tour Signal shortlist

| 25 comments

21.jpg

Five architects, including Studio Daniel Libeskind (above and below), Ateliers Jean Nouvel and Foster + Partners, have been shortlisted to design Tour Signal, a high-rise building at La DĂ©fense business district in Paris.

libeskind.jpg

French architects Jacques Ferrier Architectures and Wilmotte et Associés SA are also shortlisted.

ferrier_hermitagesq.jpg

The shortlist was announced at the MIPIM property fair in Cannes last week. Above: Jacques Ferrier Architectures.

nouvel.jpg

Above: Ateliers Jean Nouvel

projet-foster-depuis-parvis.jpg

Above: Foster + Partners

wilmotte_associes.jpg

Above: Wilmotte et Associés SA

Here's some info from competition organisers EPAD:

--

The La DĂ©fense business district is at a turning point in its development. The prime centre for European business must continue to assert and strengthen its place among the great international business districts.

With the establishment of the La DĂ©fense Renewal Plan, EPAD has undertaken a strategic and prospective study with the aim of sustainable development and architectural innovation, two aspects which play a full part in its economic attractiveness.

Therefore, in July 2007, EPAD launched an international call for projects for the construction of the Tour Signal, which forms an integral part of this plan. It is a question of exploring the organisational, programmatic, technological and aesthetic proposals that might extend and enhance the special characteristics of La DĂ©fense. Due for completion in 2015, the Tour Signal will symbolise the renewal of La DĂ©fense. This new high-rise building will add a Very High Emotional Quality to the previous symbolic and historic architectural constructions in the La DĂ©fense district, such as the CNIT and the Grande Arche.

For this call for projects, EPAD deliberately did not impose a site. The candidates were thus able to choose their sites either from among the entrances to the business district (South Gate and West Gate), either from sites subject to demolition operations. The Tour Signal will thus endow the business district with a new landmark.

Today at MIPIM, the Tour Signal project is moving into its second stage, with the disclosure of the identity of the 5 fi nalist projects that are competing for selection of the winning project, which is planned for the end of April 2008.

| 25 comments

Posted on Thursday, March 20th, 2008 at 12:12 pm by . See our copyright policy. Before commenting, please read our comments policy.

  • a_non

    is it me or do most of these look previously done?
    i.e. libeskind= freedom tower
    wilmotte=SOM http://www.som.com/content.cfm/jinling_tower

  • http://www.flickr.com/photos/halleluja jeroen

    no one seems to be able to do something surprising.
    la defense is such a dull place to me.

  • cp

    definitely lacking imagination with a couple of the proposals. I would like to see Foster+P’s taken further – slideshow of it here:
    http://www.tour-signal-ladefense.com/en/fi2d.html#

  • Dubbi

    woffffffff, all of them are HORRIBLE. I’m curious about Nouvel’s – the section doesn’t show much. Perhaps that’s the only good one. His work is dark and amazing at the same time.

  • http://plehar.com Philip Lehar

    They changed the design in NY so Libeskind is moving it to Paris.
    SOM doesn’t have the illusion of sloping floors.

  • zuy

    Wilmotte ‘s tower is not twisting…

  • tim

    hah, you know you are in trouble when SOM can out design your design firm. (note: I have nothing against SOM here, I actually respect them more than most design firms, but really…)

  • M

    what happened to the Morphosis tower on the other side of la defence?

  • tommi

    Jean Nouvel is my favourite, even it looks rather simple, but seems has more public spaces than d’ rest.

    Actually i much prefer d’ one done by Manuelle Gautrand & unlucky they are not ind finalist.

    http://tour-signal-ladefense.com/en/cd6.html

  • http://archipelagoes.blogspot.com/ Tim

    I’m not really excited by either one of the entries. It all looks a bit bland and safe. And about the Morphosis-tower: you can see it in the top-most picture, behind other buildings on the right-hand side. I am curious why Nouvel’s tower is the only one without a slick, over-photoshopped picture?

  • pan

    how zuy said, wilmotte’s tower is not twisted (unlike the one of SOM). it s three volumes with a triangular basis which are inclined to open the tower on the top and bottom – on the bottom to create a public space between the three volumes which is an open air space. that IS surprising

  • oarchi

    they are horrible !!!
    see the tordjman’s project, he was candidate, it’s great !!!
    french have bad taste, the contest is totally politic

  • oarchi
  • zuy

    Paris is branding the city …. and need to integrate an innovative skyline
    seen from Paris because the business center is outside Paris, in the suburbs … What about copyright of tower?

  • zuy
  • Billy

    the morphosis tower is in design development now and is on track for realization. given the look of these new proposals at la defense, i think the morphosis tower will still stand out as the new iconic image of the development.

  • zuy

    Paris: Serero Architects unveils its design for the extension of the Eiffel Tower top floor. The project will extend the top floor plate of the tower by grafting a high performance carbon Kevlar structure on it. The structure will be temporarily bolted to the slab without requiring any modification of the existing structure. It will expand the usable floor area from 280 m2 to 580m2.

  • zuy

    i’m agree with Billy Paris needs a new iconic image + eiffel tower ( see previous funny post)
    i’m agree with Oarchy too , but only some french presidents had bad taste…see the Bastille Opera, Bercy finance ministery, aso…

  • http://uniquechicago.blogspot.com designatedbloger

    ok so what will the public of this worthy zeen vote on, as the best for the job?

    i am curious to know!

  • zuy

    The fragtal design of american Daniel Libeskind is better for this place, we have with him a new Eiffel tower….near a new arc de triomphe
    Other drawings are so symetric:
    -we do not need an other arc de triomphe(Ferrier), it’s enought with 2,
    -nor too simple volumes as Pei pyramid or TGB(perrault) …
    - I like Foster in London, competition with paris.
    - i like Nouvel ( institut du monde arabe, Branly) ….

  • Arch

    i wonder if Miz Hadid joined.

  • giorgio righi riva

    jaques ferrier best project.

  • J.R.

    I propose Nouvels Tour Sans Fin be built at last. I felt that was elegant enough for Paris.

  • J.R.

    by the way, is there an update to the massive Les Halles project under consideration a few years ago?

  • poppins

    SDL all the way. Agreed that none are mind blowing, but at least Libeskind’s has impact. And is it really that similar to freedom tower? a) so what if it is..that ones not getting built