Santiago Calatrava wins legal battle against
"insulting and degrading" website

| 10 comments

The Palau de les Arts Reina Sofia by Santiago Calatrava

News: a political party has been ordered to pay Spanish architect Santiago Calatrava over £24,000 in damages after being found guilty of defamation with a website that accused him of "bleeding Valencia dry".

Calatrava took left-wing Spanish party Esquerra Unida to court seeking the take down of a website called Calatrava te la clava – which loosely translates as Calatrava bleeds you dry – and £485,500 (€600,000) in compensation.

The site included a number of allegations regarding costs, delays and problems with projects by the architect's firm. When it launched it focused on Calatrava's Ciudad de las Artes y las Ciencias de Valencia (City of Arts and Sciences) complex, for which the party claimed he had billed the local government €100 million, adding that he was "bleeding Valencia dry".

Palau de les Arts Reina Sofia at the City of Arts and Sciences Valencia by Santiago Calatrava
The Palau de les Arts Reina Sofia by Santiago Calatrava

The party also alleged that the project had cost more than four times its original budget, coming in at over £900 million (€1.1 billion).

A judge in Valencia ordered that the site be taken down immediately and replaced with a copy of the verdict, as well as pay the architect £24,270 (€30,000) in damages. The site published "objective truths" he said in his statement, adding that although the information on it was "within the limits of the criticism" in relation to freedom of expression, the site's name was "insulting and degrading".

Ignacio Blanco, a local politician in Valencia who is behind the site, told British newspaper the Guardian that he would probably appeal against the court's decision.

Esquerra Unida has now launched a site called Calatrava no nos calla – which roughly translates as Caltrava will not silence us – with the tag line "ruinous projects and invoices without VAT".

Palau de les Arts Reina Sofia at the City of Arts and Sciences Valencia by Santiago Calatrava
The Palau de les Arts Reina Sofia by Santiago Calatrava

Update 21/05/14: An investigation into a problem with the roof of the Palau de les Arts Reina Sofia opera house in the City of Arts and Sciences has also ended favourably for Calatrava.

Sections of the trendcadis – a type of Catalonian mosaic – on the facade of the building came away in high winds last winter prompting further controversy around the project. But an investigation into the incident has determined that the fault lay with a subcontractor responsible for the application of adhesive used to secure the mosaic tiles and not Calatrava.

Calatrava and the construction conglomerate UTE, which originally completed the opera house in 2005, are now collaborating to have the damage repaired.

Calatrava has recently been involved in a number of other disputes in Spain.

In April 2013 the owners of the Calatrava-designed Ysios winery in the La Rioja region of Spain launched legal action against the architect over a leaky roof, demanding a contribution to the £1.7 million required for its repair after repeated attempts by Calatrava's builders to fix the problem.

In June 2013, he paid €3.3 million to settle a dispute after a conference centre he designed in the northern Spanish city of Oviedo suffered structural collapse.

In Bilbao, his footbridge to the Guggenheim has caused controversy after the city had to pay compensation to pedestrians who slipped on its glass surface in wet weather.

  • Freddy Garcia

    Architecture is becoming Art-Chitecture more and more. However, it must be functional and efficient.

    • davvid

      I’m fine with artful architecture. Calatrava produces bad art. His shapes are contrived, pseudo gothic kitsch.

  • trop

    “£48,500 (€600,000) in compensation.” Close.

  • http://www.dezeen.com/ Dezeen Magazine

    Oops! We’ve corrected the typo. Thanks for pointing it out.

    Kind regards,

    Ross/Dezeen.

  • papou

    It’s too easy to blame only architects. Calatrava is a great one in my opinion and we should not forget the responsibility of clients, contractors etc.

  • Z-dog

    This is the double-edged sword of being a starchitect. By behaving as a single creator of an object, the public react to a single person if it goes wrong.

    Let’s face it, most people have no clue how the construction industry works. Generally the courts have to sort it out!

  • Juan Luis Perez

    Yeah, “Calatrava te la clava” is a bit more raunchy then the article’s translation.

  • ron b

    I feel free to say that is an ugly building and it does appear that this postmodernish style is reaching its end.

  • Tom Fry

    Calatrava rocks and he is also one of the few LEO starsign architects

  • Ritasue Siegel

    I am in Valencia now and awed by the scale of the project. If all the faults are repaired we are still left with a vision not supported by quality content. The science museum exhibit turned out to be less informative and interactive than a free pop up trailer near the beach on Illusions by La Caixa Bank. The aquarium is quite dated. I do no know to whom the content of any of the
    buildings was delegated, but clearly they have not been around the world to sample the state of the art.