Santiago Calatrava's World Trade Center transit terminal to quietly open next week

| 10 comments

The World Trade Center Transportation Hub, designed by Spanish architect Santiago Calatrava, is scheduled to partially open next week in Lower Manhattan, more than a decade after work began.

The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, which operates the terminal, has not announced a specific date, saying only that the building will open to the public the first week in March.

A photo posted by Matthew James (@gunz353) on

The terminal consists of an elliptical winged pavilion, referred to as the Oculus, which serves as the main concourse. Below ground, an extensive network of pathways link to rail and subway lines.

There is no grand opening ceremony planned for the building, which sits on the eastern edge of the 16-acre (6.5 hectare) World Trade Center site.

While exterior work on the Oculus is complete, the interior is not yet finished, so only a portion of the transit hall will open to the public. Full completion is slated for later this year, according to the Port Authority.

The transit agency's executive director, Patrick Foye, who inherited the project from a predecessor, has criticised the terminal, calling it a "symbol of excess".

"I have been troubled with the huge cost of the hub at a time of limited resources for infrastructure," Foye recently told Politico.

Since Calatrava's design was first unveiled in 2004, the project's cost has soared to $3.9 billion (£2.5 billion) – nearly double the original estimate. Calatrava has said the building will be a catalyst for development in Lower Manhattan, "in the same way that the Grand Central Station and Penn Station were previously".



"Personally, I am very proud to have participated in such a complex and unique project," said Calatrava in a statement. "I honestly believe that the station is going to follow in the footsteps of other iconic structures in the city, such as the bridges over the Hudson and the East Rivers."

Intended to evoke a bird in flight, the building has a skeletal appearance, with white walls that resemble ribs. The original scheme called for an operable roof, so that the pavilion's two "wings" could move up and down, but the kinetic aspect was eliminated due to costs.

Inside the Oculus, an operable skylight stretches 330 feet (100 metres) along the curved roof. The skylight will be opened on temperate days, but will open on 11 September each year.

The sides of the building are glazed.

A photo posted by Brett Raney (@brett_raney) on

Intended to serve as a piazza, the oval-shaped hall is paved with white marble flooring and is ringed by two levels of retail space. The western and eastern sides feature viewing platforms and tube-shaped glass elevators.

"Due to its structure and luminosity, the Oculus is a piazza for New York, the same way piazzas were traditionally understood in Europe: as a place for visiting and gathering, in which the access to the main locations of the city are articulated," said Calatrava in a statement.

The retail shells are still under construction and are expected to open by August. More than 100 tenants have reportedly leased units within the terminal, including Apple, Michael Kors and Kate Spade.

The World Trade Center Transportation Hub by Santiago Calatrava
Photograph by Jenna McKnight/Dezeen

"The combination of natural light and sculptural form give dignity and beauty to the building's lower levels and pedestrian walkways, and provide New York City with a kind of public space it has not previously enjoyed," said Calatrava.

The terminal has drawn mixed reviews from local journalists.

Justin Davidson, architecture critic for New York magazine, wrote favourably of the building, describing it as "an extravagantly idealistic creation unlike any in New York".

The World Trade Center Transportation Hub by Santiago Calatrava
Photograph by Jenna McKnight/Dezeen

"It challenges the city's public architecture to rise above habitual cut corners and rectilinear repetition," he said, adding that "the cost of beauty is often high".

David Dunlap, a New York Times reporter, similarly praised the transit hub in a story published this week.

The World Trade Center Transportation Hub by Santiago Calatrava
Photograph by Jenna McKnight/Dezeen

"It is breathtaking from the inside – luminous, intricate, uplifting and tranquil. Photos of it resemble idealised architectural renderings," he wrote.

"Its balconies, cantilevered like diving boards at either end of the elliptical hall, will become Selfie Central," he added.

But Steve Cuozzo, a real estate columnist for the New York Post, bashed the building in a recent review.

The World Trade Center Transportation Hub by Santiago Calatrava
Photograph by Jenna McKnight/Dezeen

"The Oculus, which will partially open to the public the first week in March, is as functionally vapid inside as it is outside," he said. "It's a void in search of a purpose other than to connect a bunch of subway and pedestrian corridors and concourses with one another."

The transit terminal is designed to accommodate more than 50,000 daily riders on the Port Authority Trans-Hudson (PATH), an underground rail line that connects New York and New Jersey. It also contains stations for four city subway lines.

The building replaces the original PATH rail system that was destroyed on 11 September 2001.

  • J

    One more time “Calatrava bleeds you dry”.

  • Z-dog

    Those corridors are magnificent! Reminds me of Gaudi.

  • hellfire

    I don’t understand why they keep calling it the “oculus”. It’s not an oculus, it’s a skylight. You know what has an actual oculus? The Fulton Center, and they call that the “sky reflector”. Logic.

    On topic however, this thing is, was, and always will be a massive waste of money. The budget could have brought us a better transit centre with actual functionality, or a decent transit centre and vastly improved infrastructure throughout the entire subway system.

  • Concerned Citizen

    The exterior is practically a copy of his museum in Milwaukee.

    • Jess Thinkin

      Damn fella! He thought nobody would notice!

  • Smugitecture

    What are the chances of it not leaking?

    • HeywoodFloyd

      Zero.

    • Jess Thinkin

      About the same as the chances the Calatrava man will NOT be quoted as saying: “I TRULY believe my terminal building will be New York City’s ______, _______, and _______ of our time”. You fill in the blanks with the most self-serving, grandiose, pseudo-intellectual archi-babble of your choice.

  • Logan Hendricks

    I imagine it would feel wonderful to stand at the centre of this space. 25 years from now, no one will remember what it cost, and people will still come from all over the world just to see it.

    • HeywoodFloyd

      And to go shopping!