Garden Bridge

Garden Bridge review finds "robust and informed decision-making" behind £185 million project

The charity set up to deliver Thomas Heatherwick's £185 million Garden Bridge has acted legally and responsibly, according to a report from the UK government.

The review – launched following a series of complaints about the project's managament and finances – found that the Garden Bridge Trust is "operating in compliance with charity law" and has "proper financial controls in place".

"We have been able to offer public assurance that the Garden Bridge Trust is meeting its obligations as a registered charity," said David Holdsworth of the Charity Commission, which conducted the investigation.

UK government renews support for Garden Bridge but reduces offer by £6 million
Designed by Thomas Heatherwick, the 367-metre-long Garden Bridge is proposed across London's River Thames

The report lauded the role of the charity's trustees for providing "strategic leadership" and "robust and informed decision making".

"This case shows that high-profile charities can attract considerable public scrutiny, and the public rightly expect charities to be transparent and accountable," said Holdsworth.

"Having trustees in place with the right skills and experience is crucial for a charity to operate effectively."

The 367-metre-long bridge is proposed across London's River Thames, featuring full-size trees and planting beds on its deck.

It is currently expected to cost at least £185 million, with £60 million coming from the government. Almost £40 million of that has already been spent.

Expected to cost £185 million, the bridge will boast full-size trees and planted sections along its deck

The review investigated three issues, the first being whether the construction contracts were fairly awarded, or whether there where any conflicts of interest in the process.

The findings – a four-page report published on the UK government's website – show the investigators found "no cause for concern" regarding conflicts of interest, and that the arrangements of the contracts were "robust".

However it does state that the trust could have carried out more comparisons with similar infrastructure projects to assess risks.

Assessing whether the charity has the capacity to deliver a project of this size, the inquiry was satisfied with the evidence provided, which included "clear strategy and active budget management".

The investigators also looked at whether the project's funding has been handled responsibly.

Their report states that the trust could have been more forthcoming with information about its accounts, but that "proper arrangements" appear to be in place to ensure the organisation operates efficiently.

"When observing the charity's core-management group meeting, we saw evidence that the relationship between the trustees and the senior management team balances support, scrutiny and challenge," reads the text.

UK government renews support for Garden Bridge but reduces offer by £6 million
It is set to be constructed between Temple and the South Bank

London mayor Sadiq Khan has also commissioned an inquiry into the finances of the contentious Garden Bridge, reiterating his pledge that no more public funds would go towards the project.

This separate review is being conducted by Margaret Hodge, the former chair of parliament's public accounts committee. It will look more closely at whether the project provides value for money.

First unveiled in 2013, Thomas Heatherwick's Garden Bridge design is set to be constructed between Temple and the South Bank.

The bridge is billed as a "beautiful new garden floating above the River Thames", but has been dogged by problems. Critics have included RIBA president Jane Duncan, local politician Kate Hoey, and campaigners Michael Ball and Will Jennings.

Alternative green crossings have been proposed by architects Allies and Morrison, and Crispin Wride for nearby Blackfriars Bridge, along with a variety of more satirical suggestions.

Heatherwick also has a similar project in New York – the Pier 55 elevated park over the Hudson River, which is under construction after overcoming a legal battle last year.