Fire Island House by Andrew Franz

Andrew Franz updates 1960s home on New York's Fire Island

A new guesthouse and swimming pool are among the updates to a 56-year-old home on Fire Island that has been overhauled by American studio Andrew Franz Architect.

Called Fire Island House, the residence is tucked into a wooded site near the beach. The home takes its name from its location – Fire Island, a barrier island in the Atlantic Ocean that is a popular getaway spot for New Yorkers.

Guesthouse of Fire Island House
Andrew Franz Architect added a guesthouse to Fire Island House

The project entailed the renovation and expansion of a two-storey, cedar-clad house that was designed by Florida-born architect Horace Gifford, who created dozens of beach cottages on the island. The house dates to 1965.

Manhattan-based Andrew Franz Architect oversaw the project in collaboration with interior Peter Dunham, designer Jamie Bush, and landscape architect Tania Compton.

Fire Island House on Fire Island is clad in cedar
The house has been re-clad with fresh cedar

Fire Island House involved several modifications, including a new guest house and a new swimming pool and terrace. The team also updated the original home and made various adjustments.

The goal was to create additions that were distinguishable from the original design, while also being respectful.

"I think we all fell in love with this house, and therefore only wanted what was best for her," said architect Andrew Franz.

"The project came to be so much more about protecting this iconographic modernist building, not our egos."

Restored interiors of 1960s house on Fire Island
The interiors of the modernist house have also been restored

In the new guesthouse are a bedroom and bathroom. The building's rectangular shape refers to the original home's geometry, as does its cedar siding and jalousie windows.

It was positioned to form an internal courtyard, which serves as a transition between the old and new, according to the team.

Vintage fireplace in Fire Island House
A vintage fireplace was added in the revamp

The main home's exterior was fully restored, including the installation of new cladding, copper flashing and roofing.

On one side, the team added a staircase that is cantilevered off a shear wall and connects the ground level with upper-level terraces.

Interior of Fire Island House refurbishment
Sliding doors lead out onto a deck

Inside, the designers restored wood surfaces and windows and implemented a new heating and cooling system. Small changes were made to other parts of the interior.

"Minor plan gestures were incorporated to improve circulation and function — such as enlarged bathrooms, a restored kitchen, and a vintage fireplace," the team said.

New swimming pool added to 1960s house on Fire Island
A swimming pool was also added to the house on Fire Island

The team also addressed the landscape, making sure to preserve its wild character. Scrub was cleared away and native vegetation was reintroduced, with the aim to support local fauna and foster pollination.

The property is located in Fire Island Pines, one of several communities on the barrier island. Since the mid-20th century, the car-free area has been a haven for New York's gay community, particularly in the summer.

Fire Island House exterior shot
The house in Fire Island Pines was built in the 1960s

There are a number of restored, modernist homes there, including a single-storey dwelling that received an update by Rodman Paul Architects, and a multi-level home that was revamped by Delson or Sherman Architects so it could endure hurricanes.

Photography is by Albert Vecerka/Esto and Tria Giovan.


Project credits:

Architecture: Andrew Franz Architect
Interior design: Peter Dunham
Design consultancy: Jamie Bush
Landscape architecture: Tania Compton
Garden design: CF Gardens

More images

Plans for Fire Island House by Andrew Franz
Site plan
Plans for Fire Island House by Andrew Franz
Floor plans
Plans for Fire Island House by Andrew Franz
Model