Designs of the Year prize "about architecture
rather than politics" says Design Museum director

| 16 comments

Heydar Aliyev Centre by Zaha Hadid

News: the Design Museum in London has defended its decision to give its Designs of the Year top prize to a Zaha Hadid building in Azerbaijan, following widespread criticisms of the award on human rights grounds.

"It's a prize about architecture rather than politics and its architectural quality is outstanding," Design Museum director Deyan Sudjic told Dezeen.

"The jury made a decision on what they thought was the best project. I support that decision but I played no part in making it."

Sudjic also defended the apparent London bias of the prize, which this year saw an all-London jury give the prize to a London-based architect - the fifth consecutive year that a Londoner has won the award.

"If you look at the whole range of what's in the [Designs of the Year exhibition] it's a fascinating overview of international architecture and design," said Sudjic. "[Designs of the Year] is a very international project. It's the one place where you can see that range of projects."

But he added: "We listen and we want to improve."



Sudjic's comments follow a backlash on Twitter and in the international media, after the prize for the best international design of the year went to Hadid's Heydar Aliyev Center in Baku, the Azerbaijani capital.

Human rights groups claim that residents forcefully evicted to clear the site for Hadid's cultural centre, and point to wider human rights abuses in the country including election rigging and torture of prisoners.

Guardian architecture critic Oliver Wainwright tweeted: "Zaha Hadid wins award for supporting forced evictions, illegal demolition and bonded labour- well done @DesignMuseum"

Journalist and critic Tom Dyckhoff of The Culture Show tweeted: "Baffling that Zaha can't see that architecture's inherently political".

Architecture critic Owen Hatherley added: "good thing people are angry architect doesn't care about slaves making their buildings".

Former Azerbaijani human rights worker Rebecca Vincent told The Independent that the situation in the country  "is getting worse not better".

She added: "It would be really helpful if a well-known figure like Dame Zaha Hadid could raise these issues while working in the country."

Heydar Aliyev Center by Zaha Hadid

The Design Museum responded to the backlash in a statement issued this morning. "There always has and probably always will be a huge amount of debate around the ethical implications of large scale architectural projects," the statement said. "Designs of the Year always provokes a strong reaction, and the conversation around the realities of contemporary architecture is one that the Design Museum wants to be a part of."

It added: "There is no doubt that Zaha Hadid is a hugely talented architect, and this is what the Design of the Year award recognises."

The Iraqi-born British architect previously faced criticism for saying that architects have "nothing to do with the workers" who have died on construction sites in Qatar, where her stadium design is being constructed for the 2022 FIFA World Cup.

Hadid's building is named after the former ruler of Azerbaijan. Heydar Aliyev, previously a senior figure in the KGB, ruled the country during the Soviet era and became its first president following independence in 1991.

The building, which sits on Heydar Aliyev Boulevard and is located between Heydar Aliyev International Airport and the city centre, was commissioned by the former leader's son and the current president, Ilham Aliyev, who took power following his father's death in 2003.

Saffet Kaya Bekiroglu, project architect at Zaha Hadid Architects, said that the Heydar Aliyev Center represented a break with the country's Soviet past.

"They wanted to have something unique, something which is looking at the future, somehow showing their soft, romantic side but at the same time their optimistic side," Bekiroglu told Dezeen at the prize-giving ceremony on Tuesday night.

"When you look at Soviet era [architecture in Azerbaijan], it's more like monumental internalised authoritarian buildings. So, this, we wanted to use this building as an opportunity to soften it up and totally depart from that."

The 2014 Designs of the Year jury was chaired by writer Ekow Eshun and consisted of architect Piers Gough, industrial designer Kim Colin, journalist Tina Gaudoin and last year's winner, web designer Ben Terrett. All five are based in London.

Last year the top prize was won by UK government website gov.uk. In 2012 it went to the London 2012 Olympic torch, designed by Barber and Osgerby. Design of the Year in 2011 was the Plumen lightbulb while the 2010 winner was a folding plug designed by Royal College of Art graduate Min-Kyu Choi.

Zaha Hadid Architects commented: "The Heydar Aliyev Center is an important educational and cultural building and we are delighted it has won the Design of the Year award.

"The contractor that built the centre won a design-build competition employing ZHA as their architect. This contractor, DiA Holding, are assessed and certified by SGS as complying with OHSAS 18001: 2007, an internationally applied British Standard for best practice in occupational health, safety, and management. The Swiss accrediting authority SGS (Société Générale de Surveillance) is the world’s leading inspection, verification and certification company."

Photography is by Iwan Baan.

  • Soupdragon

    How can they say it’s about ‘architecture’ when only one of the jurors has even visited the building?

    Architecture is about judgements based in reality, not photography.

    • Tony

      How could YOU say otherwise, if you’ve never been there?!

  • Bruno de Paris

    Criticism regarding human rights is definitely justified here. Such a whimsical piece of work with no existential meaning is definitely a crime against humanity. Why is Zaha’s architecture praised? Architecture is not fashion, it’s a responsibility towards society and culture.

  • tommasio

    “When you look at Soviet-era architecture in Azerbaijan, it’s more like monumental internalised authoritarian buildings. So, this, we wanted to use this building as an opportunity to soften it up and totally depart from that.”

    The architecture might be wanting to show the romantic and soft side, but in reality the authoritarian aspect of the country is definitely there.

  • Didier

    In agreement with everything here but it is also, as a cynic, worth noting that Hadid owns the Design Museum building. It’s hard to see beyond that cosiness.

  • http://be.net/bassel Bassel

    Detractors ride the bandwagon driven by the grim context of this building, spamming blogs with liberal rhetoric. It is undeniable the unsubtle propaganda associated with the commissioning of this centre. One day the despotic regime in Azerbaijan will be toppled, but this building will remain a keeper, minus it’s title of course.

  • nig

    I agree. If you want to save the world, go work in policy or for an NGO or peace corps. Seriously, if you are worried about unfair labor practices, fight them. Don’t bitch about architects designing in those countries on a blog.

  • Cruz Tom

    Architecture is vanity, if it wasn’t we would all be engineers.

  • maarten

    The design museum should be ashamed, Zaha should be ashamed! Architecture is ALWAYS about politics. Just look at what’s happening in Qatar etc.

    Zaha should return the prize and reflect on what happened here, and the Design Museum should make a statement, rather than look the other way and keep repeating the same mistakes. Unfortunately this won’t be happening.

  • http://misfitsarchitecture.com/ misfits architecture

    Sweeties, architecture is all about making the clients with money look good. Don’t you get it yet?

  • Architected

    Architecture IS politics, IS engineering, IS social awareness, IS psychology. It is the order and the organisation of human space and how we communicate and interact with each other. This is why architecture is a joke now. It’s now all based on image and judged by product designers and fashion experts who think architecture is solely based on design and aesthetics.

  • http://be.net/bassel Bassel

    Or how about that Pharaoh’s tomb!

  • Giulio

    It’s the end of architecture as we know it

  • SCAQTony

    Put some railings around it and it would make a great skateboard park.

  • http://www.theidlearchitect.com/ The Idle Architect

    Apparently good clients with no money are much less attractive than bad ones with lots and lots of it.

  • Early bird

    Yeah, maybe architecture is just a picture of our society, not better and not worse, but I don’t like what I am seeing.