RIBA Stirling Prize shortlist 2009

| 9 comments
More:

ribasterling09top4.jpg

Bodegas Protos winery by Rogers Stirk Harbour + Partners (above) is one of six buildings shortlisted for the RIBA Stirling Prize 2009.

ribasterling099.jpg

The shortlisted projects are:

  • Bodegas Protos, Spain by Rogers Stirk Harbour + Partners (see our previous story)
  • Fuglsang Kunstmuseum, Denmark by Tony Fretton Architects (see our previous story)
  • Maggie's Centre, London by Rogers Stirk Harbour + Partners
  • Liverpool One Masterplan, Liverpool by BDP
  • 5 Aldermanbury Square, London by Eric Parry Architects
  • Kentish Town Health Centre, London by Allford Hall Monaghan Morris

Top image: Bodegas Protos, Spain, by Rogers Stirk Harbour + Partners. Photograph by Paul Raftery.

Above image: Bodegas Protos, Spain, by Rogers Stirk Harbour + Partners. Photograph by Katsuhisa Kida.

ribasterling093.jpg

The prize is awarded annually to the architects of the building that has made the greatest contribution to British architecture in the past year.

Above image: Maggie's Centre, London, by Rogers Stirk Harbour + Partners. Photograph by Richard Bryant/Arcaid.

ribasterling0910.jpg

The winner will be announced in London on 17 October and broadcast live in the UK by Channel 4. Last year's winner was Accordia in Cambridge designed by Feilden Clegg Bradley Studios, Alison Brooks Architects, and Macreanor Lavington. See our story about the building here.

Above image: Maggie's Centre, London, by Rogers Stirk Harbour + Partners. Photograph by Richard Bryant.

ribasterling098.jpg

See last year's shortlist here.

Here are further details from RIBA:

--

RIBA Stirling Prize 2009 shortlist announced

A pioneering health centre in London, an imposing winery in Spain, an elegant museum in Denmark and a mixed-use scheme residential scheme contributing to the regeneration of Liverpool are among the six building projects which have made it onto this year's shortlist for the RIBA Stirling Prize 2009 in association with The Architects' Journal and Crystal CG.

Above image: 5 Aldermanbury Square, London, by Eric Parry Architects. Photograph by Timothy Soar.

ribasterling0912.jpg

The prize is awarded to the architects of the building that has made the greatest contribution to British architecture in the past year.

Above image: 5 Aldermanbury Square, London, by Eric Parry Architects. Photograph by Nicholas Kane.

ribasterling095.jpg

William Hill is again offering odds on the shortlisted buildings. The six buildings competing for this year's title are:

  • Fuglsang Kunstmuseum, Denmark by Tony Fretton Architects (William Hill odds: 3/1)
  • Maggie's Centre, London by Rogers Stirk Harbour + Partners (odds: 4/1)
  • Bodegas Protos, Spain by Rogers Stirk Harbour + Partners (odds: 4/1)
  • Liverpool One Masterplan, Liverpool by BDP (odds: 9/2)
  • 5 Aldermanbury Square, London by Eric Parry Architects (odds: 9/2)
  • Kentish Town Health Centre, London by Allford Hall Monaghan Morris (odds: 5/1)

Above image: Kentish Town Health Centre, London, by Allford Hall Monaghan Morris. Photograph by Timothy Soar.

ribasterling094.jpg

Sunand Prasad, RIBA President said:
“This year’s shortlist really embodies the wide ranging spirit of the RIBA Stirling Prize: from a winery to health centres, from an art museum in open country to major transformations of dense inner city areas. This is a fascinating set of schemes; the judges have a hard but eagerly anticipated decision to make.”

Above image: Kentish Town Health Centre, London, by Allford Hall Monaghan Morris. Photograph by Timothy Soar.

ribasterling097.jpg

The RIBA Stirling Prize jury, which will visit all six shortlisted buildings and then meet for a final time on the day of the presentation to pick the winner, this year includes: Benedetta Tagliabue – architect, Sir John Sorrell – Chair of CABE and Thomas Heatherwick – designer.

Above image: Fuglsang Kunstmuseum, Denmark, by Tony Fretton Architects. Photograph by Helene Binet.

ribasterling0911.jpg

The winner of the RIBA Stirling Prize in association with The Architects' Journal and Crystal CG will be announced at Old Billingsgate, London on Saturday 17 October 2009, and broadcast live on Channel 4.

Above image: Fuglsang Kunstmuseum, Denmark, by Tony Fretton Architects. Photograph by Helene Binet.

ribasterling096.jpg

Previous winners include The Scottish Parliament by EMBT / RMJM Ltd, 30 St. Mary Axe by Foster + Partners, the Laban Centre by Herzog & de Meuron, Gateshead Millennium Bridge by Wilkinson Eyre Architects, the Museum of Modern Literature by David Chipperfield Architects, and Accordia by Feilden Clegg Bradley Studios, Alison Brooks Architects, and Macreanor Lavington.

Above and below images: Liverpool One Masterplan, Liverpool, by BDP. Photograph by David Millington.

ribasterling092.jpg

The RIBA is proud to have Autodesk, Ibstock and SIV Architectural Recruitment as Associate Sponsors of the RIBA Stirling Prize 2009.

Brief citations for each shortlisted building are included below:

5 Aldermanbury Square, London – Eric Parry Architects

The project does much to improve the urban realm of the City of London. It evolved to allow the creation of a new public space connecting Wood Street and Aldermanbury Square to the upper level of the Barbican High Walk.  The new 18-storey building sits above this public space and consists of two staggered wings that are divided by a receding central section. The two entrances are linked by a triple height ground floor reception , with a sloping floor which drops a metre from north to south. The external frame and facades are formed in shot-peened stainless steel cladding, and are arranged in double and, immediately above the base, triple height bays giving a strong sense of verticality to the elevations.

Kentish Town Health Centre, London – Allford Hall Monaghan Morris

Kentish Town Health Centre sets a new standard for the NHS. Dr Roy MacGregor has championed a building where new thinking on holistic healthcare, connectivity, flexibility and transparency were all harnessed by his team. Through its fusion of health practice, architecture and art, the resulting building is uplifting for both staff and patients. Consulting rooms and stairs enjoy views into a triple height central street and waiting area around which the plan is organised. The project champions the idea of cellular flexibility whereby consulting and meeting rooms are assigned to health staff via an electronic booking system. The project is exemplary in its approach to sustainability and includes the use of recycled materials, natural ventilation and night-time purging of internal space temperatures. Why can’t all health clinics be like this?

Liverpool One Masterplan, Liverpool – BDP

The Liverpool One Masterplan has single-handedly reversed the fortunes of the city by bringing a new social and economic vibrancy to what was 42 acres of derelict but historic buildings at its heart.  The result is a vibrant and economically successful retail, leisure and mixed-use quarter – an entirely revitalised city centre that now connects properly with the Docks. BDP set down generous public space networks and rigorous yet flexible design briefs and have worked with a broad range of architects to evolve the plan and deliver buildings of a very high quality. That one project has been able to deliver sufficient critical mass to regenerate a city of such importance is the result of an outstanding client with vision and commitment to delivering design excellence and urban coherence.

Maggie's Centre, London – Rogers Stirk Harbour + Partner

How can a building can generate an immediate sense of welcome, serenity and even love on a frantic Hammersmith thoroughfare and in the shadow of a dauntingly huge NHS hospital?  RSH’s quietly confident building is unquestionably a haven for those who have been diagnosed with cancer. Their achievement is in having created a completely informal, home-like sanctuary to help patients with cancer. Conceived as a two-storey pavilion, the architects have sheltered the centre from its harsh surroundings with a thick and cheerful orange masonry wall that also serves as a backdrop for carefully planted tree groves and gardens. Its positive spirit is signalled with a roof canopy that oversails its many intimate internal gardens and courtyards.

Bodegas Protos, Spain – Rogers Stirk Harbour + Partners

Bodegas Protos is an aspirational wine co-operative in Peñafiel, north-west Spain.  The five parallel arches of the great roof sitting on a stone plinth provide a magnificently memorable image for the Bodegas on its site overlooked by the fine medieval Castle of Peñafiel .   The handsome laminated timber trusses spring from the level of the plinth, while the terracotta tile-covered roof floats free of the purlins by means of steel arms.  Inside the building visitors find themselves overlooking a double-height space, with the fermentation and storage vessels below them.  Descending the spiral steel and glass stair visitors gain sudden views of the castle through the glazed gable of the arches far above them.  This is a very memorable building.

Fuglsang Kunstmuseum, Denmark – Tony Fretton Architects

Fretton’s design consciously eschews the two stereotypes of the modern-day art space: the flashy icon project designed to pull in the punters, and the white cube, designed to attract, rather, the opposite, a rarefied audience of connoisseurs. The client’s considered brief demanded an approachable, domestic-scale gallery which, nonetheless, had presence, and in which the studying of art by curators in the offices, and the experience of art in the galleries were connected, without getting in the way of one another. This Fretton achieves hands-down. It is well constructed and detailed, and clearly erudite, with nods in its composition to architectural history. It feels, said one judge, almost as if it could have been built in any decade since the 20s. That is quite a compliment.

The RIBA Stirling Prize is a ‘built or designed in Britain’ prize, for which only buildings in the UK by RIBA chartered members and International Fellows, or buildings in the rest of the EU by practices whose principal office is in the UK, are eligible.

The RIBA Trust manages the cultural assets of the Royal Institute of British Architects (RIBA), including the internationally recognised collections of the British Architectural Library. It is the UK’s national architecture centre, delivering the RIBA Awards and RIBA Stirling Prize (broadcast on Channel 4); the Royal Gold Medal; International and Honorary Fellowships; RIBA partnership in architecture festivals such as the forthcoming London Festival of Architecture; and a full programme of lectures, exhibitions, tours and other events; and an education programme.

2009 marks the 175th anniversary of the founding of the RIBA. To celebrate this milestone the Institute is looking forward to a programme of special events to be held throughout the year that aims to show the breadth of our activities throughout the world of architecture, engage an even wider public and celebrate the benefits to society of good design. For further information visit www.architecture.com

  • tommi

    Tony Fretton vs Eric Parry

  • http://tarjanurmi-arkkivahti.blogspot.com tarja nurmi

    very fine to have health care buildings in the shortlist. the museum in Denmark I just have to see as well

  • Nick the Greek

    I reckon Rogers is going to get it with the Maggie’s Centre (you heard it here first). 4/1 odds aren’t too bad either…

  • http://www.snowarchitects.co.uk SNOW architects

    Slightly biased by me I’m afraid – Liverpool ONE – Fantastic scheme that works really well and connects the two halves of the city centre and the albert dock.

    after all I’m Liverpool based and worked on the project myself, if it wasn’t for me that park would be 150mm to the left :)

  • http://www.danielbrowns.com Daniel Brown

    “Liverpool One Masterplan has single-handedly reversed the fortunes of the city ”

    That’s so arrogant! Liverpool One is only a small part of the *city centre* regeneration, and the jury is very much still out as to whether Liverpool’s decline has really been halted. Try going to the northern districts and ask the locals if a few expensive-high-brand stores have made it any easier for them to put food on the table. (shoplifting aside, I mean)

    After all, the Duke of Westminster (who owns Liverpool One) cited it as the reason his ranking on the UK rich list has taken a huge battering, it already being worth a fraction of its value just 18 months ago.

    That said, it is a real asset to the city.

  • andy

    crikey, a boring year for british architecture if this lot are pick of the bunch!
    surely there are some more influential/ interesting projects by british architects around?

  • Luxury Larry

    this years entry is appaling! i guess it would be both project by Rogers Stirk Harbour + Partners that got my vote!

  • zee

    YAY LIVERPOOL! MY HOME TOWN!

  • zonas

    Not impressed with BDPs work elsewhere. They have a habit of ignoring the needs of low income residents. As if they were invisible.